Storytelling is an essential tool
used in Native American Culture and one that is a prominent theme in “The Lone
Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven” Storytelling is known in history as oral
tradition (the passing of knowledge and information from generation to
generation by words) and a way the elders in the tribe were able to educate the
young members in the ways and tradition of the tribe itself. It is a survival
skill taught at a young age, but is the major focus on how storytelling
provides the tools to survive or allows for a type of escapists technique to
get away from a current social situation. In reality, it is possibly used as
both with most of the focus being drawn to the survival aspect rather than an
escapist technique.
Storytelling
in general is used in a multitude of different things such as entertainment,
education, and as tradition. It began when Indians moved to new land or were
sent to a reservation they had never seen. It became a way for the Indians to
pass down knowledge about how to survive, live off the land, and pay their
respects to past generations. It was also used as a form of entertainment on
most reservations. Three stories in “The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in
Heaven” that resemble the survival aspect through storytelling are “Indian
Education”, “The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven” and “The Trial of
Thomas Builds-The- fire”. In Indian education, the main point of the story is
to show the young life of an Indian from first grade all the way to graduation.
This story is important because it defines the struggles and obstacles that he
had to go through just to live to the end of each day on the reservation as
well as in a white society. In the lone
ranger and tonto fistfight in heaven, the main character talks about how city
life was tough to adjust to and that many other Indians believed it was a
mistake for him to leave the reservation. This is a story used for educating
the young members of the tribe on the dangers of leaving the reservation and trying
to live in a white society. The third story is the trial of “Thomas
builds-the-fire”. This story in particular describes old stories of the past
and how Indians were judged for their actions. There is also a sign of how a
white society viewed the Indians and there culture. These stories are only a
few examples of how education was passed down and mistakes were corrected.
Storytelling
as an escapist’s technique is much different from the survival aspect. This
portion focuses more on getting away from everyday life on the reservation and
pretending to get away from a certain social situation or a role they were give
in their society. These escapist techniques include dreaming and imagination.
Two stories go along with this idea of escapist terminology and they are “A
Good Story” and “Imaging the Reservation”.
The first story is a simple interaction between a boy and his mother
about storytelling. This shows that the characters in the story put a lot of
effort and attention into the stories that they told. The main focus in that
story was that the mom wanted to hear a happy story than the usual sad
story. In Imagine the reservation, there
is an emphasis on life in the reservation and the world without the white man
controlling everything. These stories are important because they provided a
sense of hope for the Indians in the reservation and give them something to
look to everyday rather than the work and poor living conditions that they had.
Indians
found that storytelling was an essential tool for bringing balance and survival
skill to each tribe and reservation. It is because of these stories that future
generations were able to survive as well as they did and provide a sense of
hope.
Storytelling
is an important tool used to describe the ways of the past so that future
generations would be able to keep and hold the traditions of their ancestors,
while at the same time be able to offer a false hope in the otherwise
unsatisfactory livelihood on the reservation. It was used as both a survival tool and an escape in the reservations across the North America.
I like how you brought up the use of story-telling as both a tradition and a form of escapism for residents of the reservation. Not only does is connect the past to the present but it also let's those in the present alleviate, at least temporarily, the hardships they must deal with on a daily basis. In that sense it's almost paradoxical...maybe? Hopefully someone can word it better than I did.
ReplyDeleteLaura, I like what you said about it being paradoxical in a way. It seems that in being a tradition of telling stories to the younger children in the tribe, they were also receiving a "way out" of the current situation that they were in. In find it interesting that even though the stories that they tell are tradition, it only provides a temporary form of escape and not one that would alter their lifestyle forever. I look at storytelling as a way to pass down tradition and become closer to the tribe first and then used as a survival technique second.
DeleteI think what you are trying to say is talking about their problems, like they are stories, helps them separate themselves from the problems for a short while. I think that is a really good observation. It makes me wonder though, if the characters in the book are helped by the stories, by alleviating stress, or hurt, because it continues this thought that this is the way things are and nothing can be done.
DeleteI agree with storytelling use a secondary survival. I believe Alexie tried to expose the strain within their nation.
DeleteJake, I liked post man, I actually have a little bit of the same points in mine. I also used the point you stated about story telling being a sort of survival skill for Native Americans. Storytelling really is just that to them though, a way to share their experiences, triumphs, defeats, and also just become closer together which is vital for them especially on the reservation where some many things can make one not want to be close to anyone for fear of it being taken away by, drugs, alcohol, injustice, and bad decisions. I definitely agree with what you said about it being a survival skill. Good job on kinda breaking down each chapter you used and showing how storytelling is expressed in each one!
ReplyDeleteThanks adam, I enjoyed reading your post as well. Would you say that the education and passing down of the tradition of storytelling comes first or that the most important part is the learning to use it as a survival skill? I guess to the Native americans, it is just a way of everyday and they don't see it as a survival skill. Maybe someone else could expand on this idea.
DeleteJake, well I think the use it as a survival skill, but it also hurts them because they can't get past their heritage of suffering at times. I think a big issue is they keep remembering heartbreaking stories of defeat as opposed to stories about overcoming challenges that oppose them. I think story telling can help if done right, but if done wrong illustrates the tribes difficulty to forget. How do y'all see the book as a whole, a bunch of sad stories that should be forgotten, or stories that need to be remembered for the hardships faced.
DeleteGreat job, Jake! Your second to last paragraph about "Indians found that storytelling was an essential tool for bringing balance and survival skill to each tribe and reservation," explains why in this story they focused on storytelling and maybe the whole point the book was written in the first place (if that makes sense). Many cultures, including the Native American, to preserve itself in a way. So, I'm really glad you touched on that!
ReplyDeleteGoing off what Lauren said and what you said in your post, I agree. Some stories that are completely imaginative, but still hold a bigger meaning, still allow its listener to forget about their current situation and escape to a place of their own. Like you said Jake, it can be used as a survival technique. Storytelling can help the mind sane with all the craziness that happens in one's life. Especially in this story.
I too appreciated the use of storytelling. The author left me with the impression that storytelling exposes if not represents the broken hopes, impossible dreams. Survival in many senses for sure.
ReplyDelete